Homemade Cookie Monster Ice Cream

Have you ever watched your kids’ eyes light up at the sight of Cookie Monster on TV? That vibrant blue fur, those googly eyes, and of course, his infamous cookie-munching enthusiasm! Now imagine bringing that same joy to your dessert table with a homemade treat that captures all the fun of everyone’s favorite fuzzy blue monster.

This Cookie Monster Ice Cream isn’t just another dessert – it’s an experience that bridges generations. The striking blue color immediately catches the eye, while chunks of chocolate chip cookies and crumbled chocolate sandwich cookies create that perfect Cookie Monster-approved texture. Each spoonful delivers the ideal balance of creamy vanilla ice cream base with delicious cookie surprises.

I first created this recipe for my nephew’s Sesame Street-themed birthday party, and the reactions were priceless. Adults were transported back to childhood afternoons watching PBS, while kids were absolutely mesmerized by eating something that looked like it jumped straight off the screen. Since then, it’s become our most requested dessert for special occasions – and I’m betting it will become a favorite in your home too!

Why You’ll Love Cookie Monster Ice Cream

• 🍪 Perfect Cookie-to-Ice Cream Ratio – Every bite contains the ideal amount of cookies without overwhelming the creamy base
• 🌱 Natural Blue Options Available – Create that vibrant Cookie Monster color with or without artificial dyes
• 🙌 Two Methods to Choose From – Complete instructions for both traditional ice cream machine and no-churn methods
• 🎉 Guaranteed Showstopper – Watch faces light up when you serve this nostalgic, visually stunning dessert

Ingredients You Need for Cookie Monster Ice Cream

For the Ice Cream Base:

• Heavy Cream (2 cups): The foundation of our rich, smooth texture. Make sure it’s very cold for the best whipping results and creamiest finish.
• Sweetened Condensed Milk (1 14-oz can): This provides both sweetness and contributes to that luscious texture without the need for cooking a custard base.
• Vanilla Extract (2 teaspoons): Adds depth of flavor that complements the cookies perfectly. Always use pure vanilla extract rather than imitation for the best flavor.
• Blue Food Coloring (1/4 teaspoon gel color or 10-15 drops liquid): Creates that signature Cookie Monster blue! You can adjust based on your desired shade of blue.
• Salt (1/4 teaspoon): A small amount enhances all the flavors and balances the sweetness.

For the Cookie Mix-ins:

• Chocolate Chip Cookies (1 cup, roughly chopped): Provide that authentic Cookie Monster crunch and flavor. Slightly underbake them for softer texture when frozen.
• Chocolate Sandwich Cookies (10 cookies, crumbled): Add visual contrast and that classic cookies-and-cream element. The cream filling helps keep these cookies from becoming too hard when frozen.
• Mini Chocolate Chips (1/3 cup): These smaller chocolate bits distribute throughout the ice cream for little bursts of chocolate in every bite.

Natural Blue Coloring Alternative:

• Butterfly Pea Flower Tea (3 tablespoons, steeply brewed and cooled): This natural ingredient creates a beautiful blue hue without artificial colors. The flavor is very mild and won’t compete with the vanilla base.

Kitchen Equipment You’ll Need

• Ice cream maker OR loaf pan for no-churn method
• Large mixing bowl
• Electric mixer (stand or hand mixer)
• Rubber spatula
• Measuring cups and spoons
• Freezer-safe container with tight-fitting lid
• Cookie cutters (optional, for shaped cookie pieces)

How to Make Cookie Monster Ice Cream

If Using an Ice Cream Machine:

1. Prepare your ice cream maker by freezing the bowl for at least 24 hours before starting the recipe. This crucial step ensures proper freezing of your ice cream.
2. Whip the heavy cream in a large bowl using an electric mixer on medium-high speed until stiff peaks form. Be careful not to overwhip, which can create a butter-like texture. The cream should hold its shape but still look smooth and glossy.
3. Create the blue base by gently folding the sweetened condensed milk into the whipped cream using a rubber spatula. Move slowly to maintain as much air as possible in the mixture. Add the vanilla extract and salt, continuing to fold until just combined.
4. Add the blue coloring gradually, starting with a small amount and adjusting until you reach that perfect Cookie Monster blue shade. For natural coloring, add the cooled butterfly pea flower tea instead, mixing thoroughly.
5. Pour the mixture into your prepared ice cream maker and churn according to manufacturer’s instructions, usually about 20-25 minutes or until the mixture resembles soft-serve ice cream.
6. Add the cookie pieces during the last 2-3 minutes of churning. Pour in about half of your cookie chunks, allowing them to distribute throughout the ice cream. Reserve the remaining pieces for layering.
7. Layer into your storage container by spreading one-third of the ice cream, then sprinkling some of the reserved cookie pieces. Repeat with remaining ice cream and cookies, finishing with a generous sprinkle of cookies on top.
8. Freeze for at least 4 hours or overnight until firm. For best texture, place a piece of plastic wrap directly on the surface of the ice cream before covering with a lid to prevent ice crystals from forming.

For No-Churn Method:

1. Follow steps 2-4 above to create your blue ice cream base.
2. Gently fold in half of the cookie pieces using a spatula, being careful not to deflate the whipped mixture too much.
3. Transfer to a freezer-safe loaf pan or container, then top with remaining cookie pieces, gently pressing some into the surface.
4. Cover tightly with plastic wrap pressed against the surface, then aluminum foil, and freeze for at least 6 hours or overnight.

Expert Tips for Cookie Monster Ice Cream

• For the perfect cookie texture, slightly underbake your chocolate chip cookies if making them from scratch. This prevents them from becoming too hard when frozen.
• Create cookie “dust” by pulsing a few cookies in a food processor and sprinkling this between layers for authentic Cookie Monster messiness. This technique distributes cookie flavor throughout every bite.
• Achieve the ideal blue color by adding coloring to the condensed milk first before folding into the whipped cream. This allows you to control the exact shade without overmixing the whipped cream.
• For special occasions, shape larger cookie pieces using Cookie Monster-themed cookie cutters for an extra fun presentation when guests discover them.

Variations and Substitutions

• Dairy-Free Option: Substitute full-fat coconut cream for heavy cream and dairy-free condensed milk. Use dairy-free cookies for the mix-ins.
• Less Sweet Version: Reduce the sweetened condensed milk to 10 ounces and add 1/4 cup of whole milk to maintain texture. This creates a slightly less sweet base that lets the cookie flavors shine.
• Cookies & Cream Monster: Use only chocolate sandwich cookies and add some crumbled chocolate wafers for a cookies-and-cream focused variation.
• Cookie Butter Swirl: For an extra indulgent twist, warm 1/4 cup of cookie butter until pourable and create a swirl throughout the ice cream just before freezing.

Serving Suggestions

Transform your Cookie Monster Ice Cream into a complete dessert experience with these creative serving ideas:

• Create Cookie Monster sundaes by adding googly candy eyes and arranging cookie pieces to look like Cookie Monster’s mouth with a cookie being devoured.
• Serve in blue waffle cones decorated with a ring of mini chocolate chips around the rim for a portable treat.
• Make ice cream sandwiches using large chocolate chip cookies – the ultimate Cookie Monster indulgence!
• For birthday parties, pre-scoop ice cream balls and freeze on a tray, then quickly assemble into a Cookie Monster face on a serving platter when ready to serve.

Storing Suggestions

This Cookie Monster Ice Cream will keep in the freezer for up to 2 weeks when stored properly. For best results:

• Keep in an airtight container with plastic wrap pressed directly on the surface.
• Store toward the back of the freezer rather than in the door to maintain a consistent temperature.
• Allow to soften at room temperature for 5-7 minutes before serving for the perfect scoopability.
• To refresh the texture after several days, let soften slightly then blend briefly in a food processor and refreeze.

Looking for more delicious recipes to try? Here are a few of our favorites:

• Croissant French Toast Recipe
• Perfect Sourdough Bread Bowls
• Chocolate Covered Almonds

Frequently Asked Questions

Print